©1998 by Robert N. Gaines. All rights reserved.

Argument Analysis of Colin Powell, "I Am a Republican," Republican National Convention, San Diego, California, 12 August 1996.


The following offers a possible analysis of Colin Powell's "I Am a Republican." Note that Powell's remarks conform to the traditional expectation that a political convention speech involves praise of the speaker's party and political candidates. Political convention speeches may also involve blame of the opposing party and poltical candidates.



                     Values are the------->The Republican----------------->Republican principles will----->We Republicans have principles
                     conscience of     |   vision rests                 |  keep the American Dream      |  and leaders that are worthy of
                     Society. (6)      |   on values. (6)               |  alive. (12)                  |  our aspirations. (16)
                                       |                                |                               |
                     Values fuel-------|                                |                               |
                     families. (6)                                      |                               |
                                                                        |                               |
                     Growth creats-------->Republicans------------------|                               |
                     wealth. (7)       | | want economic                |                               |
                                       | | growth through               |                               |
                                       | | less govern-                 |                               |
                     Wealth creates----| | ment. (8, 12)                |                               |
                     jobs. (7)         | |                              |                               |
                                       | |                              |                               |
                     Less taxation,----| |                              |                               |
                     regulation, and     |                              |                               |
                     spending fosters    |                              |                               |
                     growth. (8)         |                              |                               |
                                         |                              |                               |
Less government----->But less government |Unless less                   |                               |
spending will not    will not lack com-  |government will               |                               |
single out just      passion. (9)        |be a step back                |                               |
the poor and                             |from compassion. (9)          |                               |
middle class. (9)                                                       |                               |
                                                                        |                               |
Diversity makes----->Republicans are------>The Republican---------------|                               |
America strong.      for equal rights  |   party is the                 |                               |
(11)                 and fair oppor-   |   party of                     |                               |
                     tunity. (11)      |   inclusion. (11)              |                               |
                                       |                                |                               |
                     Republican--------|                                |                               |
                     welcome every     |                                |                               |
                     citizen equally.  |                                |                               |
                     (11)              |                                |                               |
                                       |                                |                               |
Republicans--------->Republicans-------|                                |                               |
tolerate my       |  tolerate                                           |                               |
view on           |  difference. (12)                                   |                               |
affirmative       |                                                     |                               |
action. (12)      |                                                     |                               |
                  |                                                     |                               |
Republicans-------|                                                     |                               |
tolerate my                                                             |                               |
view on                                                                 |                               |
right to                                                                |                               |
choose                                                                  |                               |
abortion. (12)                                                          |                               |
                                                                        |                               |
                     Republican ---------->The Republican---------------|                               |
                     leaders will      |   party will keep                                              |
                     bring greater     |   America the leader                                           |
                     coherence to      |   of the free world.                                           |
                     foreign policy.   |   (12)                                                         |
                     (12)              |                                                                |
                                       |                                                                |
                     Republican--------|                                                                |
                     leaders will                                                                       |
                     assure that                                                                        |
                     U.S. armed                                                                         | 
                     forces are                                                                         |
                     the strongest.                                                                     |
                     (12)                                                                               |
                                                                                                        |            
Dole proved his----->Bob Dole is a man----->Dole is best qualified by ----->Republican leaders are------| 
courage on the    |  of courage. (13)    |  beliefs, character, and      |  good, qualified persons.
battlefield. (13) |                      |  to be President. (15)        |  (14-15)
                  |                      |                               |
Dole showed his---|                      |                               |
courage overcom-                         |                               |
ing disability.                          |                               |
(13)                                     |                               |
                                         |                               |
Dole led the------->Dole is a man of-----|                               |
Senate and          distinguished        |                               |
deliberated         service. (14)        |                               |
war and peace.                           |                               |
(14)                                     |                               |
                                         |                               |
                    Dole is a man of-----|                               |
                    strength, maturity   |                               |
                    and integrity.(15)   |                               |
                                         |                               |
                    Dole is fighter of---|                               |
                    drive, energy, and                                   |
                    commitment. (15)                                     |
                                                                         |
                                            Jack Kemp is a man of--------|
                                            passion, conviction,
                                            and caring. (15)

Back to Course Page